Like I said in the title, the silver ones have a really nice shine and they look really pretty. They were also clean and looked excactly like in the pictures. The golden ones sadly not as much. While the palette looks pretty good, the color of the brushes looks meh. It seemed like it was dunked into some golden color. It wasn’t shiny at all and it looked more like it was made out of plastic but of metal. That was kinda disappointing . But like I said this problem was only with the golden brush. The envelope looked pretty nice like always and I really love the pink little box they send you everything in.